Homemade Pancake Syrup

Pancake Syrup Banner


We eat pancakes or waffles or both every weekend. We really like the change as most weekdays we eat toast and eggs with oatmeal for breakfast. So to have a special breakfast on the weekends is nice. Sometimes we do omelets with hash-browns too. Since we eat a lot of waffles and pancakes I make my own pancake syrup. This way we are not eating all that high fructose corn syrup. So here the recipe I use, it is a modified version from the Tightwad Gazette book, I changed it to make it dairy free.

Pancake Syrup


3 cups sugar
3 tablespoons of molasses
1 1/2 cups water
1-2 teaspoons of maple flavoring

In a saucepan measure out the sugar and the water and stir. Add the molasses and put on a burner on high heat. Stir until the sugar is dissolved. Once the sugar is dissolved let it cook on the burner until a rolling boil is reached. You want it really boiling rapidly.


Once a good rolling boil is reached go ahead and turn off the burner but don’t remove the pan from the burner. Let the pan sit on the burner until it is done bubbling. Once done bubbling remove from the burner and let cool or you can use it warm.


I store mine in an old syrup bottle in the refrigerator. This recipe will fill one bottle full.


I hope you have success in making this recipe. Later this month I will be posting my recipe for blueberry sauce which we use on our waffles and pancakes too.

If you have a great syrup recipe please leave us a comment or a link to your recipe.

If You Liked This Recipe...

Subscribe and Get Recipes Sent to Your Inbox!

Sign up below and each time we have a new recipe to share, it will be sent directly to your inbox. 

For Subscribing!


Sharing is caring!

4 thoughts on “Homemade Pancake Syrup”

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


The Elf on the Shelf Printable Pack 

Sign up below to join the Frugal Family Home Community and we'll send you money savng ideas, kitchen tips and recipes right to your inbox. Plus, you'll get the Elf on the Shelf Printable Pack too. 


Don't Worry We Won't Spam You, We Hate Spam as Much as You Do!

Sign Up!

Thanks for Signing Up!

Soon you'll be getting an email with your Elf on the Shelf Printable Pack.


If you don't see it in a few minutes, be sure to check your spam or promotions folder. Sometimes they will hide in there. 

Recipe sign up photo

Get New

Recipes Sent to Your Inbox

Join the Frugal Family Home Community

and get new recipes, cooking tips and more sent right to your inbox. 

Don't Worry We Won't Spam You. We had Spam too! 

Privacy Policy

Sign Up for the Email List

and get the Calendar Pack for Free

Enter your name and email address below and you'll be signed up to recieve money saving tips, new recipes, and more. And we'll get the calendar pack out to you right away!

 We Won't Spam You, We Hate Spam Too

Privacy Policy and Disclaimer

When You Sign Up...

You'll not only get the Holiday Planner, but you'll also get our 10 day take control of your holidays e-course. It will help you plan your holidays. Sign up below to get started...


Don't Worry We Won't Spam You, We Hate Spam Too!

Privacy Policy